When the Review Isn't Real

‍

You open Google one morning and there it is: a one-star review from someone you have never heard of, describing a job you never did, for an address that is not in your service area. Your stomach drops. Your rating just fell from 4.8 to 4.5, and you know what that means: fewer calls.

‍

This happens more often than most contractors realize. Competitors, former employees, and confused homeowners leaving reviews on the wrong profile all contribute to fake and inappropriate reviews on Google. Research estimates that roughly 30% of all online reviews may be inauthentic, and Google itself blocked or removed 240 million policy-violating reviews in 2024 alone.

‍

Even a single fake one-star review can visibly drop your average rating and impact your Google Business Profile reviews performance in local search results.

‍

 And since the majority of homeowners check Google reviews before calling a contractor, that drop translates directly to lost estimate requests and lost revenue.

‍

The good news: Google has a process for flagging and removing reviews that violate its policies. Most contractors just do not know the steps. This post walks you through exactly what qualifies for removal, the step-by-step process for flagging and appealing, and what to do while you wait.

‍

‍

What Google Will (and Won't) Remove

‍

‍

Before you flag anything, you need to understand Google's line. Google will only remove reviews that violate a specific content policy.

‍

They will not remove a review just because it is negative, unfair, or factually wrong. If a real customer had a bad experience, even if you disagree with their account, that review stays.

‍

If you’re unsure how negative reviews impact visibility, see why customer reviews are critical for contractors. 

‍

Here is what does qualify for removal:

‍

• Spam and fake engagement: Reviews from people who were never customers. This includes review farms, purchased reviews, and reviews posted by bots.
• Off-topic content: Reviews that are not about your business or the service you provided. Political rants, personal grudges unrelated to your work, or reviews clearly meant for a different company.
• Conflict of interest: Reviews from competitors trying to tank your rating, former employees with an axe to grind, or anyone with a direct financial interest in your business.
• Harassment and threats: Reviews that contain personal attacks on you or your crew, doxxing (posting personal information), or threats of any kind.
• Offensive or hateful content: Discriminatory language, hate speech, or obscene and vulgar content used gratuitously.
• Impersonation: Someone pretending to be a different person or another business.

‍

This distinction matters. If a homeowner writes a one-star review saying your HVAC install took longer than promised, that is not removable. It is a legitimate customer experience, and your best response is a professional reply. Save the flagging process for reviews that genuinely violate Google's rules.

‍

‍

‍

The Step-by-Step Flagging Process

‍

‍

Google gives you a clear escalation path. Think of it as four rungs on a ladder. Start at the first step and move up only if needed.

‍

‍

Step 1: Flag the review from your Google Business Profile

1. Log into your Google Business Profile dashboard.
2. Click 'Read reviews' to see your full review list.
3. Find the offending review and click the three-dot menu (or the flag icon).
4. Select 'Report review' and choose the violation type that best matches.
5. Submit your report. Google typically evaluates within several days, though it can take longer.

‍

That is it for the initial flag. Google reviews the report and makes a decision. If they agree the review violates policy, it gets removed. If not, you can escalate.

‍

‍

Step 2: Track your report in the Reviews Management Tool

Google offers a dedicated Reviews Management Tool where you can check the status of every review you have reported. Statuses include 'Decision pending,' 'Report reviewed, no policy violation found,' or 'Escalated.' Bookmark this tool so you can follow up without guessing.

‍

‍

Step 3: Appeal if your initial flag is denied

If Google's initial review does not result in removal, you get one appeal. Go back to the Reviews Management Tool, select the denied review, and click 'Appeal eligible reviews.' You can appeal up to 10 reviews at once. Write a clear, factual explanation of why the review violates policy. Google will email you their final decision.

‍

Important: you only get one appeal per review. Make it count. Include specific evidence: screenshots of the reviewer's profile showing no history of using your services, customer records showing no matching name or address, or proof the reviewer is a competitor.

‍

‍

Step 4: File a Business Redressal Complaint for coordinated attacks

If you are dealing with multiple fake reviews posted in a short timeframe (a coordinated attack), skip the one-by-one approach and go straight to Google's Business Redressal Complaint Form. This form goes to a human spam review team. Provide your business name, Google Maps URL, and a detailed written explanation with evidence. You will receive a case ID, but Google does not send follow-up communication. Check back in two to three weeks.

‍

‍

New in 2025: Report review extortion scams

A wave of organized review extortion scams has been targeting home service contractors. The pattern: someone posts multiple one-star reviews on your profile and then contacts you via WhatsApp or Telegram demanding payment (usually $50 to $250) to remove them. Google now has a dedicated Merchant Extortion Report Form specifically for this scenario. If this happens to you, do not pay. Report it through the form and document everything.

‍

‍

How to Manage the Damage While You Wait

‍

‍

Google's review process takes time. You might wait days or weeks for a decision. In the meantime, the fake review is sitting on your profile. Here is how to limit the damage.

‍

‍

Respond publicly to the flagged review. Even if you know the review is fake, write a calm, professional response. Something like: 'We have no record of this service at the address described. We have reported this review to Google for investigation. If you are a customer of ours, please contact us directly at [phone] so we can address your concerns.' This tells every future homeowner reading your reviews that you are attentive and professional.

‍

‍

Increase your review velocity from real customers. The single best defense against a fake review is ten real ones. If one fake one-star review dropped you from 4.8 to 4.5, ten genuine five-star reviews will push your average right back up. This is where having a consistent review collection system matters. When you ask every customer after every job, you build a volume of proof that makes any single fake review nearly invisible.

‍

‍

Document everything for potential legal escalation. Take screenshots of the fake review, the reviewer's profile, and any communications related to extortion attempts. If the review causes measurable financial harm, this documentation becomes important. The FTC's rule banning fake reviews, effective October 2024, carries civil penalties up to $51,744 per violation, which means the legal landscape is shifting in your favor. Learn more about the FTC's crackdown on fake reviews and what it means for contractors.

‍

‍

‍

Your Best Defense: A Proactive Review System

‍

‍

Flagging fake reviews is reactive. It is something you do after the damage has already started. The real protection is a system that builds a steady stream of authentic reviews from real customers, on every job, in every neighborhood you serve.

‍

‍

When you have 150 reviews and someone drops a fake one-star, it barely moves your average. When you have 12 reviews and someone drops a fake one-star, it is devastating. Volume is your shield.

‍

If you only do three things after reading this:

‍

1. Flag the review. Follow the steps above. Start with the GBP dashboard and escalate if needed.
2. Respond publicly. Be professional, factual, and brief. Do not argue.
3. Build your review volume. Set up a system that asks every customer after every job. Consistency beats intensity.
4. ‍

The best protection against inappropriate reviews is not a better flagging process. It is a review system that runs on its own. See how automated review collection and management tools make it easy to build the kind of review volume that keeps fake reviews from hurting your business.

‍

‍

Want a quick look at what is holding back your visibility? Book a demo and we will walk you through what to fix first. No fluff.

‍

‍

‍

‍

FAQ

‍

‍

‍

Can one fake Google review actually hurt my business?

‍

Yes — especially if you have a smaller number of reviews. A single one-star review can drop your average rating enough to reduce trust and decrease call volume from homeowners comparing contractors.

‍

How do I know if a Google review is fake or eligible for removal?

‍

Reviews may qualify for removal if they come from non-customers, competitors, or contain harassment, spam, or off-topic content. Negative reviews from real customers typically cannot be removed even if you disagree with them.

‍

What should I do immediately after spotting a fake review?

‍

First, flag the review through your Google Business Profile. Second, respond publicly in a calm and professional way so future customers see that you are attentive. Third, continue collecting real reviews to protect your rating while waiting for Google's decision.

‍

Do fake reviews affect Google Maps rankings?

‍

Yes. A sudden drop in rating or engagement can impact how often your business appears in local search results. Maintaining steady review volume and responding professionally helps minimize ranking impact.

‍

How do contractors protect themselves from fake reviews long-term?

‍

The strongest defense is consistent review collection after every job. High review volume reduces the impact of any single fake review and strengthens your overall local visibility and credibility.

‍

‍

‍